Ninja Creami Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe

You need just 4-ingredients to make this Ninja Creami Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream. It's creamy, it's healthy, and it's totally delicious! You can even make it high protein.

In case you don't know, I'm absolutely obsessed with my Ninja Creami ice cream maker. If you're debating whether it's worth it or not, it is 100% worth every penny! I use it almost daily and love that I can make healthy, dairy-free ice cream easily at home with just a few basic ingredients. It's always just as creamy and delicious (if not more so) than store-bought! It's certainly cheaper in the end, that's for sure.

This recipe is not only a vanilla ice cream recipe, but my base Ninja Creami recipe. You can easily start with this recipe and blend in other flavors or mix ins depending on your mood (like some cocoa powder, fruit of choice, or favorite mix-ins like cookies). I'll refer back to this very recipe in many other posts as it's used as the base for a lot of my ice cream centered desserts.

Recipes to Serve This Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream with

Blueberry Crumble Pie

Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Berry Crumble Cake

Strawberry and Raspberry Cake

Strawberry-Peach Crumble

Why You'll Love This Recipe

• Healthy ice cream: you heard me- healthy homemade ice cream! This creamy vanilla ice cream is completely vegan, gluten free, and refined sugar free. It can also be considered paleo and AIP depending on the variety of milk/yogurt you choose. It's made with just 4 simple ingredients (5 if you want to add protein) and no added guar gum, other gums, or fake flavorings like many store-bought dairy free ice creams contain. Many Ninja Creami recipes call for using instant pudding mix as a thickener, but that is filled with artificial flavors and colors. We don't need that for a delicious vegan ice cream!
• Low sugar and low fat: regular ice cream is LOADED with sugar and often made with heavy cream, but my recipe uses just a couple of tablespoons of natural sweeteners for a light and low glycemic treat you can feel good about. We also use (dairy free) yogurt as the main fat, so you're getting some gut healthy probiotics in your dessert.
• It's easy to make: this is such a simple recipe! All you do is whisk together a few ingredients, freeze, and spin. It's that simple! There is no need to heat the base, temper eggs, or wait 20+ minutes for the ice cream to churn.

Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream Ingredients

• Dairy-free milk: I opt for coconut milk as I find it results in the creamiest outcome, but you can use almond milk, oat milk, or any other milk you like!
• Dairy-free yogurt: I again opt for a coconut milk yogurt, but any dairy-free (or dairy full) yogurt will work. This just adds a bit of fat for better texture and flavor.
• Maple syrup: be sure to use pure maple syrup.
• Vanilla extract: vanilla ice cream is a classic flavor, so be sure to use pure vanilla extract for the best results.
• Protein powder: This is optional, but I love getting the protein boost! I use Sprout Living pea protein since it has no added flavors or sugars.You can use your favorite protein powder though and can even opt for a flavored one to make Ninja Creami protein ice cream.

How to Make Ninja Creami Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream

1. Whisk or blend all of the ingredients together until smooth.
2. Pour base mixture into a Ninja Creami pint container to the max fill line, place storage lid on top, and freeze for 12-24 hours. Be sure the pint is sitting on a level surface in the freezer.
3. Before spinning, microwave the ice cream base for 30 seconds or run the outside under hot water for a minute.
4. Add the pint to the Ninja Creami container and add the outer bowl lid.
5. Spin on the lite ice cream setting. If the ice cream is chalky after the first spin, add a splash of milk and re-spin until you have a creamy ice cream.

Substitutions and Variations

• Milk and yogurt: you can combine this into one ingredient by using full fat canned coconut milk. You can also feel free to use any variety of milk or yogurt you like, including dairy products. If you can tolerate dairy, try Greek yogurt for an added protein boost!
• Maple syrup: you can sub this for coconut sugar if desired.
• Vanilla: opt for vanilla bean powder if you want those vanilla bean specks! You could even try using vanilla bean paste for a stronger vanilla flavor.
• Protein: I have also tested the plain Prime Protein beef protein which results in a fluffier texture, but is still delicious! If you use this protein, blend everything in a blender, do not try to whisk it as this protein gets clumpy easily.
• Variations: this is just a base recipe, so feel free to mix in fresh fruit, chocolate chips, peanut butter, or whatever you love!

How to Store Leftover Ninja Creami Vanilla Ice Cream

If you don't finish your vegan vanilla ice cream, smooth over the top of the pint and re-freeze any leftovers. You can re-spin the ice cream when ready to eat the rest, following the same directions as above.

Tips for the Best Dairy Free Vanilla Ice Cream:

• Heat the base before spinning. I always suggest microwaving the frozen ice cream base for 30 seconds or running the outside under hot water for a minute or two to soften the ice cream base some for best results. This helps with ice crystals and the number of times you have to re-spin for a creamy texture.
• Don't overspin! It can be tempting to keep re-spinning your ice cream for an even smoother texture, but eventually it will be more like a milkshake. If you are new to the Ninja Creami ice cream machine, it might take a few tries before you learn just how many times to spin your ice cream mixture for the perfect creamy texture that still holds its scoop.
• The official Ninja Creami book recommends adding a tablespoon of cream cheese (or vegan cream cheese in this case) for the best outcome and many people online opt for pudding mix as a low calorie option. I don't find that you need either and, but the pea protein works great if you decide to add it (although not necessary).

FAQ

Loved this Ninja Creami dairy-free vanilla ice cream? Here are more dairy free Ninnja Creami recipes

Blackberry Ice Cream

Cinnamon Ice Cream

Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream

Golden Milk Ice Cream